Posted by: Doug Henwood | June 17, 2011

Latest on Social Security

Following on the NYT quote, I thought it’d be good to post LBO’s most recent take on Social Security:

Is the real problem Social Security?

Also, this is from my radio commentary for tomorrow:

Speaking of austerity, the Wall Street Journal reported on Friday that the AARP, nominally an interest group fighting on behalf of older Americans, has decided to stop resisting calls for cuts to Social Security benefits, reversing its long opposition to such a cruel move. The group’s policy chief, John Rother, said, “The ship was sailing. I wanted to be at the wheel when that happens.” But of course he’s not going to be at the wheel. His turn is going to make it a lot easier for bad people to take the wheel. He’s already emboldened such types, within hours of the publication of the Journal’s story.

Rother was apparently inspired to make this change by the news that Obama is planning to tackle Social Security sometime in his first, and perhaps only, term as president. I’ve long thought that it’s going to take a Democrat to cut Social Security (and, along with it, Medicare), since Republicans would attract too much opposition.

Social Security is not a serious problem. Talk of its imminent bankruptcy is way overblown, and is based on extremely gloomy economic and demographic assumptions. But even if those come to pass, the numbers are actually quite small by the standards of the federal budget. For example, if you just removed the cap on the Social Security tax—wage and salary income above $106,800 is now exempt from the tax, as is investment income—then Social Security would be solvent as far as they eye can see, even given the bearish underlying assumptions. So this is a non-problem.

AARP has essentially become an insurance company. It opposed single-payer because it sells health insurance (though they’ll give you a lot of nonsensical policy justifications for their self-interested stance). I wouldn’t be surprised at all if it’s now looking to expand into the retirement annuity business. But if Social Security cuts go through, catfood might be a more promising line of business.

Advertisements

Responses

  1. aside from its value as a heavily freighted symbol, i’d suggest the issue at hand isn’t or hasn’t ever been the alleged impending ‘bankruptcy’ of social security, but rather the vast pool of wealth the program actually represents. john rother and his mendacious ilk merely demonstrate their willing complicity in attempting to make these funds available for eventual misuse and/or outright theft by the more predatory actors in the private sector. does anyone seriously believe in the wake of the TARP bailouts etc that aging boomers will actually be able to claim these funds as their own in the coming years? think again.

  2. […] Latest on Social Security from LBO News from Doug Henwood by Doug Henwood […]

  3. see article here for AARP statement opposing cuts to Social Security and Medicare

    http://www.aarp.org/politics-society/government-elections/info-07-2011/aarp-responds-obama-deficit-reduction


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Categories

%d bloggers like this: